12th Gemini Cup 結果報告

画像

<Team Prize>

 

Champion

ICU A(Yuki Tanaka,Shunichi Arai,Takuto Kobayashi)

 

Finalist

Sophia A(Kazumasa Miki,Darla Cornett,Yo Kojima)

 

Semi Finalist

Keio A(Yuki Oka,Mitsushi Ono,Lisa Pretty)

WAD A(Ryosuke Takahashi,Junko Nakano,Masanori Hayashi)

 

Quarter Finalist

Hit-u B(Yusuke Ueda,Roy Sano,Misato Tanaka)

Seikei A(Naoki Iwasaki,Wataru Hotta,Kento Funaki)

UT A(Kuwa Inokuchi,Tadayoshi Nakachi,Tomomi Sakurai)

UT B(Hiroki Ishii,Yuki Inoue,Han Chanhi)

 

Octo Finalist

Hit-u A(Noritaka Kon,Tomoya Yonaga,Go Shimizu)

ICU C(Marina Nakamura,Leon Daisuke Obermaeumer,Ayane Nomura)

ICU D(Naoko Arai,Tatsuya Hayashi,Satoshi Fujiwara)

Titech A(Junya Suzuki,Fumiaki Todo,Ryutaro Oikawa)

TMU A(Hiroki Nakajo,Kaname Yoshisue,Sumika Yamaguchi)

UT D(Kazuki Taniyoshi,Akihiro Watanabe,Marishi Mochida)

UT E(Yuki Sato,Mayuko Takahashi,Yusuke Iwata)

UT F(Kohei Funato,Natsuki Takamura,Akito Misawa)

 

<Speakers Prize>

 

Best Speaker

Mitsushi Ono(Keio A)

 

2nd Best Speakers

Yuki Tanaka(ICU A)

Yuki Oka(Keio A)

 

4th Best Speaker

Lisa Pretty(Keio A)

 

5th Best Speakers

Shunichi Arai(ICU A)

Riko Onishi(ICU B)

Naoki Iwasaki(Seikei A)

Darla Cornett(Sophia A)

Junko Nakano(WAD A)

 

10th Best Speaker

Shintaro Okawa(UT C)

 

<Breaking Teams>

1st:Keio A

2nd:UT A

3rd:WAD A

4th:Hit-u A

5th:ICU A

6th:Seikei A

7th:Sophia A

8th:UT B

9th:UT E

10th:ICU C

11st:UT D

12nd:ICU D

13rd:Hit-u B

14th:Titech A

15th:TMU A

16th:UT F

 

<Breaking Adjudicator(in no particular order)>

Aiko Imai(ICU)

Akinao Kosaki(Seikei)

Akira Kato(UT)

Anna Otake(TMU)

Fumi Inoue(UT)

Fumihiko Sano(UT)

Hiroki Taya(Keio)

Jonathan Borock(ICU,Sophia)

Kaycee Matsuda(Sophia)

Kenta Yoneyama(Keio)

Kohei Arakawa(ICU)

Max Crylov(Hit-u)

Naoto Soda(WAD)

Nobuaki Kaneoya(UT)

Ryosuke Shimoyama(AGU)

Shuntaro Seki(ICU)

Takehiro Kamei(WAD)

Takenori Hayashi(WAD)

Toshiaki Ikehara(ICU,WAD)

Yongrak Jeong(Kyoto)

Kohki Sasaki(CA)

Kazuki Tomimoto(DCA)

Kei Furuta(DCA)

Stevensen(DCA)

Yuki Tominaga(DCA)

 

 

<Motions> 

Round 1 Theme Education

THBT universities should not give academic credit for volunteer work.

THW allow teachers to physically punish their students at school regardless of parental consent.

THW pay teachers progressive salary according to the academic performance of their students

 

Round 2  Theme Legal Status

THW abolish the minimum age requirement for marriage.

THW criminalize the membership of criminal organizations, even if he/she doesn’t commit crimes on his/her own.

THBT voting eligibility should be based on the passing of civic tests instead of age.

 

Round 3 Theme International Relations

THBT it is legitimate to use aid to buy votes in international organisations.

THBT after a humanitarian intervention has halted human rights abuses, the occupation forces should leave at once if the population so wishes

THBT Israel should assassinate Iran’s nuclear scientists.

 

Round 4 Theme Environment

THW forcibly remove the homeless from the streets and place them in rehabilitation.

THBT carbon trading is more effective in combating global warming than emission tax.

THW make the development of eco-friendly industry a condition for receiving non-emergency aid.

 

Oct Final Theme The end justifies the means.

THBT evidence which is illegally obtained should be admissible in criminal trials.

THW take and use the organs of executed death row convicts regardless of consent.

THBT the 3rd world countries should recognize the necessity of sweatshops.

 

Quarter Final Theme Justice 

THBT the protection of the environment should be considered a mitigating factor when sentencing eco-terrorists.

THW impose progressive fine on offenders based on their assets.

THW abolish enhanced punishment based on hate crime law.

 

Semi Final Theme Freedom

THW allow public servants to criticize their government.

THW prosecute parents who take their children to another legal jurisdiction in order to carry out an act which is illegal in their home country.

THW legalize sadomasochism.

 

Grand Final Theme Public Discourse

THBT entertainment awards should not be bestowed on individuals who have committed crime.

THW ban publication of political opinion polls.

THW televise the executions of criminals.

 

12th Gemini Cup アンケートのお願い

この度はGemini Cupへのご参加誠にありがとうございました。

運営におけるトラブルにより、参加者の皆様には多大なご迷惑をお掛けしたことを深くお詫びいたします。

来年のGemini Cupの参考にさせていただくためにも、参加者の皆様には以下のURLからアンケートへの回答をお願いいたします。

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/viewform?formkey=dFlFS3hSZkh1bFYwSDgwNTdjWXRCNEE6MQ

なお、Teams Score,Speakers Scoreにつきましては、アンケートにご回答いただいたあと表示されるページに掲載してあるURLから閲覧することができます。

また、以下が今大会で出たモーションですので、参考にしてください。

<予選>

R1

Theme Education

THBT universities should not give academic credit for volunteer work.

THW allow teachers to physically punish their students at school regardless of parental consent.

THW pay teachers progressive salary according to the academic performance of their students

 

R2

Theme Legal Status

THW abolish the minimum age requirement for marriage.

THW criminalize the membership of criminal organizations, even if he/she doesn’t commit crimes on his/her own.

THBT voting eligibility should be based on the passing of civic tests instead of age.

R3

Theme International Relations

THBT it is legitimate to use aid to buy votes in international organisations.

THBT after a humanitarian intervention has halted human rights abuses, the occupation forces should leave at once if the population so wishes

THBT Israel should assassinate Iran’s nuclear scientists.

R4

Theme Environment

THW forcibly remove the homeless from the streets and place them in rehabilitation.

THBT carbon trading is more effective in combating global warming than emission tax.

THW make the development of eco-friendly industry a condition for receiving non-emergency aid.

<Break Round>

Oct

Theme The end justifies the means.

THBT evidence which is illegally obtained should be admissible in criminal trials.

THW take and use the organs of executed death row convicts regardless of consent.

THBT the 3rd world countries should recognize the necessity of sweatshops.

 

QF

Theme Justice

THBT the protection of the environment should be considered a mitigating factor when sentencing eco-terrorists.

THW impose progressive fine on offenders based on their assets.

THW abolish enhanced punishment based on hate crime law.

SF

Theme Freedom

THW allow public servants to criticize their government.

THW prosecute parents who take their children to another legal jurisdiction in order to carry out an act which is illegal in their home country.

THW legalize sadomasochism.

GF

Theme Public Discourse

THBT entertainment awards should not be bestowed on individuals who have committed crime

THW ban the publication of political opinion polls.

THW televise the executions of criminals.

ご回答どうぞよろしくお願いいたします。

Pre Gemini 2012 結果報告

先日行われましたPre Geminiへのご参加、誠にありがとうございました。

運営において数々のトラブルがありましたことをこの場をお借りしてお詫びいたします。

今回のPre Geminiでの反省点を生かし、Gemini Cupではよりよい運営ができるよう、頑張って参りますので、Gemini Cup当日もどうぞよろしくお願いいたします。

 

1.Pre Gemini 結果報告 

《Team Prize》

Best Team

Keio A(Mitsushi Ono/Yuki Oka/Lisa Pretty)

 

2nd Best Team

ICU A(Yuki Tanaka/Shunichi Arai/Takuto Kobayashi)

 

3rd Best Team

WAD A(Masanori Hayashi/Junko Nakano/Ryosuke Takahashi)

 

4th Best Team

ICU B(Miki Hosaka/Hirohito Asai/Riko Onishi)

 

5th Best Team

Seikei A(Naoki Iwasaki/Wataru Hotta/Kento Funaki)

 

6th Best Team

Sophia A(Kazumasa Miki/Darla Cornett/Yo Kojima)

 

7th Best Team

Hit-U A(Noritaka Kon/Tomoya Yonaga/Go Shimizu)

 

8th Best Team

AGU A(Kojiro Sakamoto/Keisuke Takashima/Hayato Hirai)

 

9th Best Team

UT A(Kuwa Inokuchi/Tadayoshi Nakachi/Tomomi Sakurai)

 

10th Best Team

WAD B(Yuki Kawana/Seoyoung Park/Rika Takemoto)

 

《Speaker Prize》

Best Speakers

Shintaro Okawa(UT C)

Shunichi Arai(ICU A)

 

3rd Best Speaker

Mitsushi Ono(Keio A)

 

4th Best Speakers

Yuki Oka(Keio A)

Lisa Pretty(Keio A)

 

6th Best Speakers

Junko Nakano(WAD A)

Hirohito Asai(ICU B)

 

8th Best Speakers

Yuki Tanaka(ICU A)

Darla Cornett(Sophia A)

 

10th Best Speakers

Naoki Iwasaki(Seikei A)

Ryosuke Takahashi(WAD A)

 

 

《Motion》

Round 1 Theme:Smoking

THW prohibit pregnant women from drinking and smoking.

THW allow companies to refuse to hire smokers.

THW ban smoking in public places.

 

Round 2 Theme:Compensation

THW give more vores to the poor.

THBT professional sporting leagues should be responsible for sports-related injuries and conditions for the lifetime of their athletes.

THBT corporations should be held responsible for abuses committed by their contracted service providers.

 

Round 3 Theme:Be Natural

THS artificial genetic enhancement of humans.

THW ban castration for pets.

THW return national treasures to their country of origin.

 

Round 4 Theme:International Relation

THBT the West should arm rebels in Syria.

THBT each of Asia,Africa and Middle East should have its own permanent regional tribunal which prosecutes individuals for genocide,crimes against humanity and war crimes.

THBT the UK should return Falkland Islands to Argentina.

 

2.結果のタブの公開について

Team Score,Speakers Scoreのタブにつきましては、以下のURLにて公開しております。

 

・Team Score

 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoOO2xjj4iKHdHg5Y0ZIUkRXT3htZUhjamtfQjdFVGc

 

・Speakers Score

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoOO2xjj4iKHdHNMM3U1MTJ3UWZJdjdleUtkVExFWVE#gid=0  

 以上がPre Geminiの結果報告となります。

Gemini Cup当日もどうぞよろしくお願いいたします。